Texts show envoy’s alarm over Trump-Ukraine plan

Text message from Bill Taylor asks: "Are we now saying that security assistance and WH meeting are conditioned on investigations? Text message from Gordon Sondland replies: "Call me."
Image caption Top US diplomats Bill Taylor and Gordon Sondland’s text messages were released on Thursday

Text messages released by Democrats in Congress reveal how US officials worked to push the Ukrainian president into opening a public inquiry into President Trump’s leading opponent, Joe Biden.

The messages come as Mr Trump faces a formal impeachment inquiry about it.

The exchanges show a senior diplomat saying it would be “crazy” to withhold military aid to Ukraine for Mr Trump’s political gain in the 2020 election.

US law bans soliciting foreign help for electoral purposes.

But Mr Trump denies any wrongdoing and, on Thursday, publicly called on Ukraine and China to investigate Mr Biden and his son Hunter over their political and business dealings, even though he has not offered specific evidence of misconduct.

He accuses his opponents of a “witch hunt”.

Impeachment in the US House of Representatives would lead to a trial in the Republican-controlled Senate.

Senators would have to vote to convict Mr Trump by a two-thirds majority to remove him from office.

What do the texts say?

The impeachment inquiry stems from a 25 July call in which Mr Trump asked President Volodymyr Zelensky to investigate his rival.

The wide-ranging text message discussions are connected to allegations by the Democrats that Mr Trump dangled military aid as a way to press Ukraine to dig dirt on Mr Biden.

Sent between July and September, they involve high-ranking officials:

  • Kurt Volker, Mr Trump’s Ukraine envoy who resigned a week ago
  • Gordon Sondland, the US ambassador to the European Union, and a significant donor to Mr Trump
  • Bill Taylor, a top US diplomat at the US embassy in Ukraine

On 19 July, the three diplomats discussed arranging a phone call between Mr Zelensky and Mr Trump.

Mr Volker told the other two he had had breakfast with Mr Trump’s lawyer, Rudy Giuliani that morning – and identified the main purpose of the upcoming phone call.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionMr Giuliani is alleged to have sought to dig up dirt on Democrat candidate Joe Biden

“Most impt [important] is for Zelensky to say that he will help the investigation,” he told the others.

But Bill Taylor, the senior US diplomat in Ukraine, warned that President Zelensky “is sensitive” about Ukraine being seen “as an instrument in Washington domestic, re-election politics”.

Ahead of the call, Mr Volker texted that he had heard from the White House that Mr Zelensky would be offered a formal visit to Washington “assuming President Z convinces Trump he will investigate / ‘get to the bottom of what happened in 2016′”.

This is a reference to unfounded allegations that Ukraine interfered in the 2016 US presidential election and worked to help the Democrats.

What were the diplomat’s concerns?

In the call, Mr Trump asked Mr Zelensky to investigate Joe Biden “as a favour”.

But text messages show US officials discussed what the Ukrainian president should say in a statement afterwards.

Image copyright Getty Images

Image caption Mr Zelensky was reportedly “sensitive” about being seen as a US “instrument”

By 13 August, Kurt Volker advised that Mr Zelensky’s statement should address interference in US politics, “especially with the alleged involvement of some Ukrainian politicians” – and Burisma, the company Joe Biden’s son was involved in.

There has been no evidence of wrongdoing by Hunter Biden.

Then, on 29 August, the tone of discussions changed. Mr Zelenksy’s aide Andriy Yermak sent a curt message to Mr Volker, including a link to a Politico story headlined “Trump holds up Ukraine military aid meant to confront Russia“.

Mr Taylor, the senior diplomat in Ukraine, seemed to voice his concerns about the motives for the delay.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionWhat we know about Biden-Ukraine corruption claims

“I think it’s crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign,” he said.

That suggestion, however, was firmly pushed back by Ambassador Gordon Sondland, who said Mr Taylor was misunderstanding the president’s intentions.

What are Democrats and Republicans saying?

In a letter alongside the release of the texts, top-ranking Democrats criticised Mr Trump’s “now open defiance of our core values as American citizens.”

“The President and his aides are engaging in a campaign of misinformation and misdirection in an attempt to normalise the act of soliciting foreign powers to interfere in our elections,” it said.

“This is not normal or acceptable. It is unethical, unpatriotic, and wrong.”

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionTrump calls for China and Ukraine to investigate the Bidens

But Republican Jim Jordan said Mr Volker’s testimony on Thursday had “undercut the salacious narrative that Representative Adam Schiff is using to sell his impeachment ambitions”.

The House Oversight Committee – of which Mr Jordan is the ranking Republican member – tweeted that “this information [contained in the text messages] cannot possibly be understood without Volker’s explanations from yesterday’s testimony”.

He has called for the entire transcript of the testimony to be released.

Donald Trump and his defenders have insisted there was no quid-pro-quo in his dealings with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Text messages between members of the US team involved in Ukrainian diplomacy, however, suggest a different story.

It was very clear to them what the Mr Trump wanted: a publicly announced Ukrainian investigation of political rival Joe Biden and the 2016 election hacking.

It also was very clear what they had to offer the Ukrainians: not only US military aid, which had been put on hold by the White House, but also a meeting between the two presidents in Washington that would have be extremely valuable in bolstering the legitimacy of the newly elected Ukrainian leader.

Drawing a straight line between the offer and the ask doesn’t take much imagination.

It may not be long before the White House falls back to its final line of defence – that threatening and cajoling Ukraine to investigate Mr Biden was justified by the egregiousness of Mr Biden’s alleged corruption.

With Mr Trump backed into a corner, it’s a recipe for all-out political warfare.

Four quick questions on Trump-Ukraine

Why is Mr Trump being investigated?

A whistleblower alleges he used “the power of his office to solicit interference from a foreign country in the US 2020 election”, by asking Ukraine to investigate his main rival, Joe Biden.

Is this illegal?

If this is what he’s proven to have done, then yes: it’s illegal to ask foreign entities for help winning a US election. Mr Trump says it’s a witch-hunt and he did nothing wrong.

What could happen next?

If the Democrat-controlled House of Representatives voted to impeach Mr Trump, there’d be a trial in the Senate.

Could he be removed?

A Senate vote needs a two-thirds majority to convict, but Mr Trump’s Republican party controls the Senate so that’s unlikely. And the Mueller inquiry made clear you can’t charge a sitting president with a crime.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *